Everything you needed to know about cooking beef (but were afraid to ask Heston Blumenthal)

by Ed on June 7, 2007

…or experiments in molecular gastronomy parts 2 and 3

RIMG0006.JPG
He’s a tricky one to have in the kitchen our Heston Blumenthal. Everything is very technical, usually takes about two days to prepare and I’m too scared to argue with him about any of his techniques. I’m even having trouble finding some of the stuff he uses like his stainless steel injection baster.

I feel that I really need to work up to his recipes. To do this I’ve recruited a couple of guys who are much more accessible than Heston, Hervé This (pronounced Teess) and Harold McGee with their excellent books Molecular Gastronomy, exploring the science of flavour and On food and cooking respectively.

My first experimental success was to cook some lamb chops to perfection at 60C. Experiment number two was with a couple of tuna steaks. They took 45 minutes at 60C in the oven but I did have to cut them open to discover whether or not they were cooked. I then browned them in a pan. Jak said they looked a little raw in the middle; 30 seconds later they were almost overdone. A mixed, but not altogether bad result.

Today it’s beef, about 750grams of a cheap single fillet steak. What I’ve decided to do is cook it until it is 60C in the centre. Apparently at 70C a chemical reaction oxidises some iron compounds turning the meat pink (I have no idea why this happens at 60C in my experiment). At 80C meat turns brown through another chemical reaction.

I’ve no idea how long my steak will take so I’m using a meat thermometer, not ideal as it pierces the flesh of the meat.

I wonder whether or not to salt the meat first in addition to peppering it and rubbing it down in olive oil. I consult This on this (that’s awkward) and apparently it makes no difference if I salt it before or after cooking.

Next, to stop the meat drying out I cocoon the whole affair with aluminium foil. Then I just leave it there in the oven, for three hours it turns out – at 60C (140F), of course.
After three hours I brown it on the outside in a frying pan (you could use a blowtorch) for a minute or two. I don’t even let this steak rest.
RIMG0008.JPG

Beef roasted at 60C (140F) for three hours.

The result is a perfect pink and extremely juicy tender steak. In my last experiment I noted that the lamb chops cooked slowly didn’t leak any juices. This chunk of steak did because of the thermometer piercing its flesh. I have learnt though that I could have sucked up the juices in a syringe and injected them back into the meat and let it sit for 10 minutes or so to absorb the juice. Next time.

There’s still a lot of experimenting to be done. I quite fancy cooking the meat for a slightly shorter time at a lower temperature so the centre is towards the raw side. And I would brown the outside for a little longer. I am simply not used to eating met that is evenly pink all the way through, although it is very enjoyable.
Food Fascist on cooking meat

Salt before or after?
It really doesn’t matter according to This.

Cook slow and cool or fast and hot?
Slow and cool produces a much more tender and juicy cut.

In the oven or poached in liquid?
These experiments have been undertaken in the oven. However, if you were to poach the meat it would absorb a percentage of the cooking liquid when cooling. This means you can flavour that liquid. Or if you are cooking in the oven you could inject it with a prepared gravy or seasoning. Perhaps even truffle (but not truffle oil, please)

What happens to a roast while cooking?
Apparently it loses one-sixth of its weight

And when you let a roast rest?
The outer parts of the roast have lost moisture. Letting it sit redistributes the juices from the centre.

What about marinades?
They do work but you want to use acids and red wines (as opposed to whites).

If you want the detailed science read the books.

Related Posts with Thumbnails Become a Facebook fan. Follow me on Twitter.

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

chadzilla June 7, 2007 at 11:20 pm

This is an easy way for all folks to explore temperature cooking as opposed to time cooking. It’s probably even easier if you have a good temperature probe that can be stuck into the direct center of the item being cooked. Herve This also explains this process through egg cookery in the introduction to the book ‘Sous-Vide’ by Roca and Brugees. He stresses that cooking is about temperature, not time. Everyone’s first question is always, “how long do I leave it in the oven?”… until the entire item reaches the desired homogenous temperature. This experiment could have also have been done through sous-vide methods. A decent food sealer or ziploc bag (just squeeze out as much air as possible) and a water bath set at a constant temperature (a little more difficult, but can be done on the stove with attention and a good thermometer). Stirring the bag around in the water frequently also helps to give it a circulating effect and keep a more uniform temperature. Small amounts of oil, liquids, or seasonings can also be placed inside the bag for an easier more effective way to flavor the meat. It only takes a tiny amount to infuse it.

neil June 8, 2007 at 9:02 am

I watched Heston do his thing with a standing rib roast on Full On Food and he was very particular about the blowtorch method, not just for colour but to kill any nasty germs that thrived on the meat at that low temperature. I’m not sure that frying off the steak would have the same effect as not all the surface of the meat comes in contact with the frying pan or grill. I don’t want my fascist to become unwell at the particular moment, before the fg.

Gregg June 8, 2007 at 9:50 am

Ed,
Like you’re other molecular tinkerings, this looks quite good. I’m interested to know how the beef tasted as compared to “traditionally” cooked fillet?
great blog BTW.
Gregg

chefjp June 8, 2007 at 11:25 am

I enjoyed your post. I find slow cooking times much more advantageous to meat. However, in a restaurant situation that seems impossible to achieve….unless people order 3 hours ahead of time (only kidding). Keep on cookin, keep on bloggin, chefjp

kitchen hand June 8, 2007 at 12:41 pm

It’s all academic if someone in your household likes their beef extremely well done.

Nowadays, I hack off a piece for myself beforehand and then pop it back into the oven fifteen minutes before the tray comes out. Result – perfectly rare and somewhat smok-flavoured by the now-charred main piece.

Matt June 8, 2007 at 5:07 pm

Hey Ed,

Great work on the experiments. Still something a bit off about cooking a steak in tepid temperatures for long periods of time… but then the science appeals to me.

Which reminds me to do something with the El Bulli spherification starter kit I bought. hrmmm…

Ed June 8, 2007 at 5:24 pm

Chadzilla,
I was in a restaurant kitchen that was showing me this the other day but I wasn’t sure about being able to keep the water at 60C. I reckon the best way to do it may be with a thermostat. They can be bought from home brew shops. Yeah, it is the temperature that is important. I am tempted by a decent probe.
Neil, I think I may be trying out the blowtorch this weekend. Of course, I have a poncy little kitchen one but luckily I dod have quite a large one from when I was attempting to become a sculpter.
Gregg, the result from cooking it at a lower temperature produced a much better juicier product. I’d go for this method every time.
Chejp, yes i gather thatis aproblem for restaurants unless you are set up for it. there are a couple around here who cook a piece at a low heat for a couple of days. Cheers.
KH, I guess the temperature method would be a bit slow for you – 3hrs at 60 degrees and another 2 hours at 80C.
Matt, you haven’t really got a spherification kit have you? I have been toying with trying it out. I had some dessert ideas.

Matt June 8, 2007 at 9:30 pm

I do indeed have one. Specifically just the Algin and Calcic, which is now sold in Simon Johnson.

I bought it in a fit of excitement a few months ago and promptly forgot it was there… I’m hoping inspiration strikes again soon.

Ed June 9, 2007 at 12:11 am

Mat,
So far I have only snuffled the truffles out from SJ but must try this. Sounds exciting.

laura February 25, 2008 at 7:34 pm

i am having a hard time finding the sferification kit do you have any suggestions on how to get my hands on one??? thanks.

Ed February 25, 2008 at 8:39 pm

Depends where you are in the world. There’s the Feran Adria kits that are available from Simon Johnson or the Raymond Capaldi ones from the Melbourne Food Ingredient cafe. Abroad try googling the Ferran Adria kits.

Viagra November 25, 2009 at 3:22 am

Erectile dysfunction, generic viagra, 5012, [URL=http://www.viagrausageneric.com/]generic viagra[/URL], o):, http://www.viagrausageneric.com/ Viagra, nthsn.

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Additional comments powered by BackType

Previous post:

Next post: